Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama July 25, 1986, Civ. 5420 (Board, Dental Examiners, Ala. v. Franks)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-07-1986

BRADLEY, Judge.

This is an appeal from the trial court’s issuance of a temporary injunction.

This action began when Dr. James Franks (Franks), a duly licensed dentist, filed a complaint for declaratory judgment which alleged that Act 85-697 was unconstitutional. The complaint further alleged that the members of the Board of Dental Examiners (Board) were engaged in the arbitrary, capricious, unequal, and discriminatory enforcement of that provision of Act 85-697, now section 34-9-19(c)(10), Code 1975, which provides: “(10) All advertisements shall contain, in legible print, the following language: ‘No representation is made about the quality of the dental services to be performed or the expertise of the dentist performing such services.’ ” (emphasis added)

It was alleged that the Board was requiring dentists who placed advertisements over one and one-half inches by one and one-half inches in size in the South Central Bell Yellow Pages to include the above disclaimer while not requiring the same disclaimer to be used in advertisements which are under one and one-half inches by one and one-half inches in size. Franks contends that his business will suffer irreparable harm if some advertisements (such as his) have disclaimers and others do not, for the public will then infer that the dentists without disclaimers are more qualified than the ones with disclaimers. The complaint urged no delay in determining Frank’s rights because the deadline for submitting Yellow Pages advertising was imminent.

Franks also filed a motion for temporary injunction, asking the trial court to enjoin the Board from enforcing section 34-9-19(c)(10) in such an arbitrary, capricious, unequal, and discriminatory manner.

A hearing on the motion for a temporary injunction was held in May 1986. Subsequently, the trial court ordered that, based on Lyon v. Alabama State Bar, 451 So.2d 1367 (Ala.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.