Supreme Court of Connecticut November 18, 1986, 12847 (Boehm v. Kish)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-11-1986
Shea, J.
The principal issue1 in this appeal is whether evidence of the defendants’ reckless service of alcohol to the plaintiff, the plaintiff’s intoxication, and the severe injuries subsequently sustained by the plaintiff while operating his automobile are sufficient to support an inference of causation in fact between the injuries and the defendants’ actions, absent testimony or other evidence that explicitly concerned the nature of the accident that produced those injuries. We conclude that the plaintiff’s failure to present any evidence of how the accident occurred in support of the causal inferences the jury might have drawn linking the plaintiff’s intoxication to his injuries necessitated a judgment for the defendants.
*387The plaintiff brought this action in two counts against the defendant cafe owner and his bartender. In the first count the plaintiff alleged liability for wanton and reckless conduct. In the second count the plaintiff alleged liability for gross negligence. Each count alleged that the defendants, in violation of General Statutes § 30-86,2 had served alcoholic beverages to the plaintiff while he was already in an intoxicated condition, and that such conduct had resulted in the injuries subsequently sustained by the plaintiff in operating his automobile. Each count further alleged that “the plaintiff lost control of the automobile and crashed into the guard rail,” although no evidence was adduced at trial to support this allegation.3
It is not disputed that the following facts are reasonably supported by the evidence: On May 7, 1981, the plaintiff, Gregory T. Boehm, drank a quart of beer and then drove for approximately ten minutes to the Brook Cafe in Westport, a bar owned by the named defendant, Paul J. Kish. At the cafe, the plaintiff ordered a total of six large drinks of rum and orange juice from the bartender, the defendant Michael Zieff, with each drink containing three to five ounces of eighty proof rum.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit