Michigan Court of Appeals January 21, 1986, Docket No. 81297 (Kiesel Intercounty Drainage Board v. Hooper)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-01-1986
Beasley, J.
Defendants, Allan and Sharon Hooper, appeal as of right from a grant of summary judgment in favor of plaintiff, Kiesel Inter-county Drainage Board, under GCR 1963, 117.2(2) *383and (3), now MCR 2.116(C)(9) and (10). The dispute involved a drain established in 1905. Defendants jointly owned land through which the drain flowed. Plaintiff claims that defendants were interfering with its right-of-way by placing junk cars along the bank of the drain, thereby interfering with plaintiff’s cleaning, deepening, widening and straightening of the drain. Defendants denied the existence of a valid right-of-way, alleging that the original 1905 release of right-of-way had not been signed by the property owner and, further, had not been recorded or registered until 1974. Defendants also claimed that a 1976 conveyance of right-of-way, signed by defendant Allan Hooper, was not valid since it was not signed by the joint owner of the land, defendant Sharon Hooper.
At the hearing on the summary judgment motion, plaintiff abandoned any claim under the 1976 grant of right-of-way from defendant Allan Hooper. However, the existence of a 1905 document granting an easement in the drain purportedly running three rods (slightly less than 50 feet) from the center line on each side of the drain was established. This 1905 release of right-of-way was on file with the Bay County Drain Commissioner. Plaintiff further stated at the hearing that it only wished to use the six-rod width provided in the 1905 release of right-of-way.
Defendants challenged the validity of the 1905 release of right-of-way by asserting that the 1905 property owner never signed the document. The abstract of title indicated that in 1905 the property was owned by Joseph Carl Warner, but the right-of-way was granted by Charles Warner, the son of Joseph Carl Warner.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit