Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 31, 1986, No. 86-491 (In re Terry)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1986

*112Memorandum Opinion

The Sullivan County Probate Court has transferred questions asking whether there are circumstances in which it would have authority under RSA 464-A:25 to authorize a guardian to order the removal of a nasogastric tube supplying food and water to the ward, a hospital patient described as living in a “chronic vegetative state.” We respectfully decline the interlocutory transfer and remand the case to the probate court.

The legal questions sought to be raised may well be of first impression in this jurisdiction, but the stipulated factual basis for the transfer is too tentative and incomplete to demonstrate that the circumstances of the case actually raise those questions. Although a stipulation of facts for the purpose of an interlocutory transfer always carries some risk that the facts would not exactly bear out the stipulation, and that any answer of transferred questions would therefore be inappropriate to the actual case, the court is especially cautious of accepting such a risk when it carries consequences for the life of a person who is not a conscious party to the proceeding.

We will not, therefore, consider the transferred questions without the benefit of the judge’s comprehensive findings of fact, made after evidentiary hearing in open court. Without limitation, the findings should address these questions:

1. Was the patient, Doris Terry, legally competent before her hospitalization? If so, what if any expression of preference did she make about the application or withholding of procedures to sustain her life in the event she should become incompetent to accept or reject such procedures?

2. If she made such an expression, under what circumstances did she do so, with what knowledge of options and their likely effects upon her, and to whom?

3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.