Montana Supreme Court December 30, 1986, 86-190 (State Ex Rel. Chisholm v. District Court of the Seventeenth Judicial District)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1986

combined-opinion

No. 86-190

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

1986

STATE, ex rel., THOMAS ANC DONALD

CHISHOLM,

Relators,

-VS-

THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH

JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF

MONTANA, IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF

VALLEY, THE HON. R.C. McDONOUGH,

THE DISTRICT JUDGE PRESIDING,

Respondents.

ORJGINAL PROCEEDING:

COUNSEL OF RECORD:

For Relators:

Erik B. Thueson argued, Great Falls, Montana

For Respondent :

Habedank, Cumrning, Best, Maltese & Savage; Robert

Savage argued, Sidney, Montana

Hon. Russell McDonough, District Judge, Glendive,

Montana

Submitted: September 9 , 1986

Decided: December 3 0 , 1986

Filed: DEC 3 0 1986

Mr. Justice John Conway Harrison delivered the Opinion of the

Court.

This case is before the Court on a petition for a writ

of mandamus pursuant to § 27-26-101, MCA, Art. VII, § 2 of

the Montana Constitution which allows a petition of

supervisory control, and Rule 17, M.R.App.Civ.P., which

allows the issuance of extraordinary writs when there is not

a speedy and adequate remedy by appeal. We decline to issu-e

the writ.

The relators (Chisholms) filed a suit against Nelson

Corscadden for conversion in the District Court of the

Seventeenth Judicial District, in and for Valley County,

Montana. Before the case came to trial, Corscadden filed for

bankruptcy. Chisholms then filed a complaint against First

National Bank of Glasgow, Montana, in the same court. Th.e

complaint alleging the Rank secretly conspired to deprive

them of their property rights in certain property which is

the subject of the action against Corscadden. Subsequently,

Chisholms petitioned the bankruptcy court to abstain from

asserting jurisdiction to allow them to proceed against

Corscadden, but the court refused.

Shortly before the trial against the Bank was scheduled

to begin, the Bank moved the District Court for partial

summary judgment as to ownership of any disputed property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.