District Court, S.D. New York October 1, 1986, No. 85 Civ. 5074 (GLG) (Richter ex rel. Reedman v. Russo)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-10-1986

GOETTEL, District Judge:

The defendants move to dismiss this action for lack of federal jurisdiction. Upon the facts, as set forth below, we conclude that the defendants’ motions must be granted.

Anna Richter, a woman in her 80’s, was a resident of the Yorkville area of Manhattan for fifty years. She was generally regarded as a neighborhood eccentric who spent a lot of time walking her two dogs. She owned the building in which she lived at 315 East 85th Street, as well as an adjacent building, 317 East 85th Street. Christina Reedman alleges that she rented an apartment at 317 East 85th Street in 1964, and claims to have known Anna Richter since that time. In 1972, Richter sold 317 East 85th Street; Reedman still lived there. In December 1980, Reedman was seeking a new apartment and spoke to Richter about moving into 315 East 85th Street. According to Reedman, Richter allowed her and her three children to move into the fourth floor apartment if Reedman agreed to repair the boiler.1 In January 1981, Richter accused Reedman of stealing boiler parts and evicted her. Reedman and her three children then moved in with attorney Thomas J. Kavanagh, who lived a few blocks away. Reedman married Kavanagh a few months later.

Reedman contends that, despite being evicted and accused of theft by Richter, she continued to help the elderly woman. On September 25, 1981, Reedman brought Mrs. Richter to Metropolitan Hospital because of the latter’s poor physical and mental condition. After doctors treated Richter for vermin bites and cleaned her up, she was referred for a psychiatric evaluation. The psychiatrist determined that Richter was somewhat senile and needed a structured, supervised setting because she was unable to care for herself. Reedman, with Kavanagh as her attorney, initiated a proceeding to have conservators appointed for Richter.

On December 8, 1981, a competency hearing took place before Justice Blangiardo, of the Supreme Court, New York County.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.