District Court, D. Maine November 17, 1986, Crim. Nos. 86-00043 P, 86-00044 P (United States v. Jeffords)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-11-1986
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER SANCTIONING COUNSEL FOR MOTION PRACTICE
GENE CARTER, District Judge.
Defense counsel has filed in the above two cases a total of twenty-six pretrial motions, thirteen in each case. On November 4, 1986 the Court entered in Criminal No. 86-00043 P its Order striking three motions as not being appropriate to that case because not “drawn with specific reference to the facts and issues in this case.” Order of November 4, 1986. Those motions were obviously “knock-off” motions of similar motions filed in Criminal No. 86-00044 P, a conspiracy case. The former case is not one involving a conspiracy charge, so the motions were not germane to any fact at issue or to any legal issue generated in Criminal No. 86-00043 P.
This Court has now spent a total of two and a half hours reviewing the remaining defense pretrial motions and the government’s responses to those motions in these two cases. The Court concludes that not more than three of the motions were in any way necessary or resulted in the resolution of any truly disputed issue of either fact or law. They are, in short, almost without exception, “make-work” motions, filed for purposes which the Court is unable to discern. They surely have the effect of making the occasion for the performance of needless work because they have generated the need for government’s counsel to prepare two responses to these motions, both of them of some thirty-five pages, the bulk of which consists of recitation of facts showing that the motions were not necessary in the first place. The Court has been required to review the motions and responses in order to determine that in each instance no genuine issue existed. Further, in no case was any motion properly supported, in the view of this Court, with a researched and informative memorandum of law as required by this court’s Local Rule 19.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit