District Court, N.D. Illinois May 7, 1986, No. 85 C 7523 (Plambeck v. Stone)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-05-1986

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

DECKER, Senior District Judge.

Plaintiffs have filed a five count complaint against the Village of Wheeling, Illinois (Village), and certain of its police officers. The defendants move to dismiss certain portions of the complaint.1

I. Factual Background

The complaint contains the following allegations which, for purposes of this motion, are taken as true. On October 11, 1983, defendants William Stutzman (Stutz-man) and John Stone (Stone), wearing plain clothes, traveled in an unmarked police vehicle to the plaintiffs’ home in Arlington Heights, Illinois, to serve an arrest warrant upon plaintiff Gerald Plambeck. Plambeck was at home with his family — Anita Plam-beck, Shari Plambeck, Cindy Plambeck, Anita Plambeck, Jr. (a minor), Christine Wrenn, and Alisa Wrenn (a minor).

Stutzman and Stone met Gerald Plam-beck and informed him of their purpose. Plambeck asked the officers to produce the warrant, but the officers did not do so. Plambeck then attempted to place a phone call to the Arlington Heights police. At *300that time, a fight broke out. Allegedly without provocation, Stutzman began choking Gerald Plambeck. Shari and Cindy Plambeck came to Gerald Plambeck’s aid. By plaintiffs’ account, Stone and Stutzman assaulted Gerald, Anita, Shari, and Cindy Plambeck. Plaintiffs claim Anita Plam-beck and Anita Plambeck, Jr. were also pushed, shoved and beaten. Christine and Alisa Wrenn witnessed these events.

At some point, defendant Thomas Lorenz, another officer, arrived and assisted Stone and Stutzman in handcuffing Gerald Plambeck. At that time, Lorenz allegedly choked Anita Plambeck. Gerald, Cindy and Shari Plambeck were arrested, handcuffed and transported to the police station. Gerald Plambeck was charged with aggravated battery, resisting a peace officer and criminal damage to property. Shari Plambeck was charged with battery and aggravated battery. Cindy Plambeck was charged with battery.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.