District Court, S.D. New York November 14, 1986, No. 85 CIV 5290 (LBS) (Imperial Commodities Corp. v. S.S. Maria Auxiliadora)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-11-1986

OPINION

SAND, District Judge.

This is an action in admiralty brought by Imperial Commodities Corporation, a New York corporation which is an importer and distributor of coffee, against Affiliated FM Insurance Company (“FM”), a Rhode Island corporation which issued an all-risk warehouse-to-warehouse policy insuring plaintiff’s cargo. Also named as a defendant Companhia De Navegacao Marítima Netumar (“Netumar”), the carrier of the cargo of coffee here at issue, and FM has cross-claimed against Netumar. The following constitutes our findings of fact and conclusions of law.

Plaintiff shipped aboard the S.S. Maria Auxiliadora, a vessel owned by Netumar, 3,000 bags of coffee, 132 pounds net, which it had contracted to sell to Barzula, a roaster in Toronto, at $1.54 per pound. Plaintiff noticed this shipment to FM at a stated insured value of $673,200 (plaintiff’s Exh. X). The coffee was loaded in Brazil in eight containers, the perimeters of which were lined with kraft paper. The shipper was responsible for the stowing of the bags within the containers which were delivered to the carrier in sealed condition. Prior to the loading of the coffee, samples were taken which disclosed that the coffee was firm, green, in good condition, of the highest quality and suitable for export.

On December 29, 1984, Netumar issued clean bills of lading acknowledging receipt of the 3,000 bags of coffee in apparent good order and condition. The S.S. Maria Auxiliadora proceeded northward. The captain of the vessel testified by deposition that no ventilation was afforded the coffee for the period January 13th through January 27th, the date of discharge in Montreal. The vents were kept closed to avoid water or moisture entering the holds of the vessel where the containers were stored and to protect against the sudden drop in outside temperature during the period January 19th through January 27th when the vessel entered northern waters.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.