Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit February 25, 1986, Nos. 85-1239(L), 85-1403 (Western World Insurance v. Harford Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-1986

TERRENCE WILLIAM BOYLE, District Judge:

Both parties to this suit for declaratory judgment provided insurance to the City of Cambridge, Maryland and its police employees. However, the risks insured, while similar, were not identical. Nor was the coverage identical. Under certain facts, an insurer would have primary coverage, while under other facts, its coverage would be excess.

Western World Insurance Company, Inc. (hereinafter “Western”) commenced this suit against Harford Mutual Insurance Company (hereinafter “Harford”) to determine, as between these insurers, which had the duty to defend, and which had the duty to pay, claims against their mutual insured arising out of a civil rights suit.

The district court, 602 F.Supp. 36 (D.C. Md.1985), after a bench trial, determined that: (1) Harford had a duty to defend the City of Cambridge and its police chief in the civil rights suit, but that Harford was *560not obligated to defend Police Officer Mears in that suit and, (2) the conduct of Officer Mears, giving rise to the civil rights action, was not a risk covered by the Harford policy. Therefore Harford was under no obligation to indemnify Western for the settlement of $45,000 that Western made with the plaintiff in the civil rights suit.

On these findings and conclusions, the court allowed Western a partial recovery of its costs of defense in the civil rights suit and awarded attorney’s fees in this suit to Western as a prevailing party. Both parties appeal from the adverse portions of the district court’s judgment.

On appeal, Western argues that the district court erred in absolving Harford of its duty to defend Officer Mears. Consistent with this argument Western seeks reimbursement from Harford of the full settlement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.