District Court, District of Columbia May 5, 1986, Civ. A. No. 85-3367 (Sedgwick v. Giant Food, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-1986

MEMORANDUM-ORDER

GASCH, Senior District Judge.

This case is before the Court on plaintiffs’ motion for a new trial. For the reasons stated below, that motion is denied.

I. BACKGROUND

This case was a diversity action for damages arising from a February 22,1984 collision between plaintiff’s car and a van driven by a Giant Food employee. As a part of her case, plaintiff alleged that the injuries she suffered in the accident caused her to develop epilepsy, which, in turn, would cause her to suffer a significant loss of future wages. This epilepsy claim had been a part of the case since at least December, 1985.

Trial of the case initially was set for April 7, 1986. In March, plaintiff was informed that defendant had retained Dr. Michael W. Dennis, a neurosurgeon, to examine plaintiff in connection with the epilepsy claim. On March 27, defendant notified plaintiff that Dr. Dennis would be called as an expert witness. Also on that date, defendant’s counsel notified plaintiff that Dr. Samuel J. Potolicchio, another expert in the field of neurology, would testify on defendant’s behalf.

Plaintiff responded by moving to exclude the testimony of these two experts. This Court denied that motion, but continued the trial for one day to allow plaintiff’s counsel to depose the two experts. These depositions were taken as scheduled. At no time before or during the trial did plaintiff move for a continuance on the ground that additional time was needed to prepare a response to the experts’ testimony.

Trial of the case began on April 8. The jury returned its verdict on April 10, finding for plaintiff in the amount of $41,000 for medical expenses, lost salary, and mental anguish. The verdict also stated, “Jury rules against plaintiff in case of epilepsy occurring as a result of Feb. 22 accident.” Plaintiff then filed the instant motion, which seeks a partial new trial only on the question of plaintiff’s epilepsy claim.

II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.