Alaska Supreme Court July 10, 1987, S-1704 (Meier v. State, Board of Fisheries)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-07-1987
OPINION
MOORE, Justice.
Joseph Meier challenges the validity of 5 AAC 06.370(b), a Fish and Game regulation governing commercial sockeye salmon fishing in Bristol Bay. Meier is a commercial salmon fisherman who operates drift gill-net gear in Bristol Bay. The superior court entered summary judgment upholding the regulation.
1
We affirm.
Fish and Game regulations divide Bristol Bay into a number of fishing districts. 5 AAC 06.200. A commercial salmon fisherman must register in a district before he may fish there. 5 AAC 06.370(a). The regulation challenged in this appeal, 5 AAC 06.370(b), requires a salmon fisherman who wishes to transfer from one district to another to register in the new district at least 48 hours before transferring, and to cease fishing in any district during the 48-hour period.
2
The waiting period is not insignificant, since the typical sockeye salmon run lasts only about ten days.
The Board of Fisheries promulgated 5 AAC 06.370 in 1986. In so doing, the Board returned to a scheme it had relied on for many years. The Board deviated from the 48-hour waiting period for only one year, in 1985. Regulations effective during 1985 permitted a fisherman to transfer 24 hours after registering in a new district, and to fish in the original district during those 24 hours.
Commercial salmon fishermen may operate either set gillnet gear or drift gillnet gear in Bristol Bay. 5 AAC 06.330. Setnet fishermen work from shore, and generally remain at the same location throughout the season. Driftnet fishermen work exclusively from boats, and are by definition more mobile. Although some driftnetters confine their activities to one area of the Bay, others prefer to “follow the fish.” The percentage of the total fish harvest achieved by setnetters depends on the number of driftnetters fishing offshore. If driftnetters saturate an area, few fish reach the beach where setnetters have an opportunity to catch them.
An obvious effect of the waiting period in 5 AAC 06.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit