New Mexico Court of Appeals December 17, 1987, 9146 (State, Department of Transportation v. Romero)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1987

OPINION

BIVINS, Judge.

This appeal comes before this court for decision after the case was submitted to an advisory committee pursuant to an experimental plan. See Boucher v. FoxworthGalbraith Lumber Co., 105 N.M. 442, 738 P.2d 1325 (Ct.App.1986). The committee unanimously recommended a decision reversing the district court. This court has considered the transcript and briefs, together with the opinion of the advisory committee. We adopt the opinion of the advisory committee, as modified.

The State of New Mexico, Transportation Department, Motor Vehicle Division (MVD), plaintiff-appellant, appeals from an order of the district court overturning MVD’s decision to revoke the driver’s license of defendant-appellee Jesse Romero. The issue on appeal is whether the district court erred in finding that no reasonable grounds existed for MVD’s revocation of Romero’s license to drive, based on the record of the administrative proceeding. Because we determine that reasonable grounds did exist in the record, we reverse.

FACTS

An Española police officer arrested Romero for driving while intoxicated. Probable cause for the arrest is not an issue. After arresting Romero, the officer explained the implied consent law and advised Romero that a failure to take the breath test could result in the revocation of his driver’s license.

Romero attempted three times to blow up the balloon. He first blew up the balloon to approximately one and one-half inches, the size of a “dollar coin.” The officer explained that the balloon had to be inflated twelve to fourteen inches in diameter for the test to be effective. Romero failed to blow up the balloon on the next two tries *and told the officer he could not fully inflate the balloon because of pain he felt from an injury he had received to his foot. After Romero failed on the third try, the officer stated that he would consider Romero’s actions a refusal to take the test. The officer administered no other tests.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.