District Court, W.D. Arkansas May 22, 1987, Civ. 85-5147 (Cooper Communities, Inc. and Subsidiaries v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1987

MEMORANDUM OPINION

H. FRANKLIN WATERS, Chief Judge.

This is a suit for the refund of federal income taxes alleged to have been overpaid for the tax years 1979 and 1980. The overpayment was the result of a ruling of the Internal Revenue Service disallowing the deduction, as an accrued expense, of the commission expenses associated with the sale of lots.

Cooper Communities, Inc. (hereinafter CCI), is an accrual basis taxpayer with the exception of utilizing the installment method of reporting income from the sale of residential lots. CCI’s fiscal year ends in September. For the taxable years in issue, a deficiency was assessed against and ultimately paid by CCI. This suit was filed after a timely claim for refund was disallowed.

This case is now before the court on cross motions for summary judgment. The parties have filed a stipulation of facts together with attached exhibits. As the stipulation of facts is detailed, the court will state only so much of it as is necessary to an understanding of the parties’ arguments.

During the tax years involved, CCI was engaged in the sale of residential lots. Sales of residential lots were made through real estate salesmen retained by the plaintiff on an independent contractor basis.

Plaintiff’s sales of lots were made largely on credit, the purchasers making a down payment (usually 10 percent) and agreeing to pay the balance in monthly payments over a period of 10 to 15 years. Sales were financed by CCI through an installment contract or a promissory note and mortgage. After the period provided for by law for the rescission of the sales contract, the sale of the particular lot was regarded by plaintiff as “cured.” When the sale became cured, it was recognized by plaintiff for financial and accounting purposes.

The terms of the salesmen’s independent contractor relationship were not reduced to writing but were pursuant to a binding oral contract.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.