United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Montana April 2, 1987, 19-60106 (In Re Stanhope)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-04-1987

ORDER

JOHN L. PETERSON, Bankruptcy Judge.

The Trustee has filed objections to the claim of exemptions of the Debtor in two items of personal property, a Rolex Presidential wrist watch valued at $5,000.00/$6,-000.00 and a vehicle, unspecified, valued at $1,000.00.

Under 25-13-611, MCA, the Debt- or may claim as exempt one clock and all wearing apparel. Exemption statutes are to be liberally construed for the benefit of the Debtor.

MacDonald v. Mercill,

714 P.2d 132 (Mont.1986). Under 25-13-611, MCA, there is no dollar limit placed on the exemptions of a clock or wearing apparel and, in accordance with

MacDonald v. Mercill,

it would be improper for the Court to do so.

Id.

at 135. While the Debtor contends the watch is a “clock” within the meaning of § 25-13-611, MCA, I think the better reasoning is that it constitutes wearing apparel as held in

Morissey v. Carter,

113 Okl. 182, 240 P. 727 (1925), where the Supreme Court of Oklahoma decided that “wearing apparel” is not confined to clothing but includes ornamentation, thereby holding a watch and chain may be wearing apparel. This position has been followed in

In re Goldberg,

59 B.R. 201 (Bankr.Okl. 1986) and

In re Mims,

49 B.R. 283 (Bankr.E.D.N.C.1985), where the court has cited a number of state court decisions holding the same result. The Trustee concedes such point, but argues that the watch valued at over $5,000.00 is a personal investment, not necessary wearing apparel. The Trustee relies on language from

In re Goldberg,

supra, which held a watch was exempt as wearing apparel, but a gold chain and gold ten dollar coin pendant were more than “just ornamentation”, represented an investment and therefore not exempt. See also

Wikle v. Westhem,

642 F.2d 1139 (9th Cir.1981), where the court held a $3,000.00 diamond ring was exempt as necessary wearing apparel, and was not an investment item.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.