District Court, N.D. California November 19, 1987, C-86-5234 MHP (Simons v. County of Marin)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1987

OPINION

PATEL, District Judge.

Around midnight on April 2, 1986, plaintiff Fred Martin Simons was mistakenly arrested pursuant to a seventeen month old warrant. Plaintiff, his wife, Cheryl Si-mons, and the couple’s three children were removed from their home and the police searched the Simons home without benefit of a warrant. Plaintiffs brought this action for damages under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 on behalf of themselves and their three minor children for violation of the rights secured to them under the fourteenth and fourth amendments to the Constitution, also asserting pendent state law claims. The action is now before the court on defendants’ motions for summary judgment. Having considered the declarations, excerpts from depositions, documents, memoranda and arguments submitted by the parties,

1

for the reasons set forth below, the court grants the motions in part and denies them in part. Defendant Marin’s motion for summary judgment is continued pending further discovery. FACTS

The series of events leading to the mistaken arrest of Fred Martin Simons (“Fred”), the removal of his wife Cheryl and their children from their home and the warrantless search of their house began in southern California, where deputy sheriff Robert John Minty, a warrant investigator for Orange County, was updating outstanding warrants for residents of Midway City on the county’s computer system. This was done by entering street addresses into the computer, which would respond with the names of persons residing in (or whose last known address was in) that area and for whom there were outstanding warrants. On March 18, Minty randomly entered a block of addresses on Van Burén Street and came up with, among others, an outstanding warrant for one Fred

Michael

Simons. On that day, Minty did nothing further, as the time allotted for updating warrants had expired.

Minty returned to the results of the March 18 search on April 2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.