Court of Appeals of Wisconsin March 3, 1987, 85-2371 (Rupert v. Home Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-03-1987

combined-opinion

138 Wis.2d 1 (1987) 405 N.W.2d 661 Scott W. RUPERT, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. HOME MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY and Catherine A. Pire, Defendants-Respondents. No. 85-2371. Court of Appeals of Wisconsin. Submitted on briefs September 11, 1986. Decided March 3, 1987. *4 For the plaintiff-appellant, there were joint briefs by Ralph W. Koopman of Eagle River, and Thomas N. Akey of Minocqua. For the defendants-respondents, there was a brief by John E. Bliss of Tinkham, Smith, Bliss, Patterson, Richards & Hessert of Wausau. Before Cane, P.J., LaRocque and Myse, JJ. CANE, P.J. Scott Rupert appeals an order dismissing his action against Home Mutual Insurance Company and Catherine Pire. The trial court dismissed the complaint because it concluded that Rupert had failed to diligently prosecute the action. Rupert argues that the dismissal violated his due process rights because he had no warning of what conduct constituted failure to prosecute an action. While we agree that the dismissal for failure to diligently prosecute violates due process under the facts of this case, we determine that the trial court has discretionary power to dismiss for failure to respond to interrogatories in a timely fashion. We conclude that the propriety of the exercise of such discretion, however, depends on further factual findings. Accordingly, we reverse and remand for further proceedings. *5 Rupert filed suit against Pire on July 30, 1984, claiming damages caused by a collision between the motorcycle he was riding and the car she was driving. Rupert also named Home Mutual, Pire's insurer, as a defendant. Home Mutual filed an answer on August 9, 1984. Rupert filed a request for production of documents on August 13, 1984. The next day, Home Mutual noticed Rupert's deposition. Home Mutual complied with Rupert's request for production of documents on August 20, 1984. On or about the same day, Home Mutual served a set of written interrogatories on Rupert.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.