Louisiana Court of Appeal May 6, 1987, 18686-CA (Tahoe Corp. v. P & G GATHERING SYSTEMS)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-1987

506 So.2d 1336 (1987) TAHOE CORPORATION, a Utah Corporation & William H. Deal, Trustee for Tahoe Corporation, Appellants, v. P & G GATHERING SYSTEMS, INC., Gas Transportation Corporation, William B. Brown & William H. Krutzer, Appellees. No. 18686-CA. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit. May 6, 1987. *1338 Shotwell, Brown & Sperry by George Wear, Jr., Monroe, and McKeithen, Wear, Ryland & Woodard by George M. Wear, Columbia, for appellants. Brown, Wicker & Amman by Ralph J. Wicker, Monroe, for appellees. Before HALL, SEXTON and NORRIS, JJ. NORRIS, Judge. This is a suit for quantum meruit or breach of the obligation to perform in good faith. The plaintiff, Tahoe Corp., claims that it continued to sell natural gas to defendant, P & G, even though P & G refused to negotiate a better price for Tahoe. To prove damages, Tahoe introduced evidence of numerous other transactions between the defendants and other sellers, as well as evidence of a federal maximum price. It argued that the relationship between the corporate defendants encouraged them to depress the price they paid to Tahoe, thereby enriching themselves at Tahoe's expense. The trial court found that the original contracts were valid and that Tahoe and P & G terminated their contract in 1981. The court also found that the parties entered an oral agreement from which Tahoe had the option of receding at will. Under this new agreement, P & G offered to continue receiving Tahoe's gas in 1981, but only at the same price as they were then paying. Since Tahoe chose to continue dealing with defendants and they paid pursuant to the oral offer, the court dismissed the suit. Tahoe now appeals, assigning as error: (1) the finding that Tahoe had other options for marketing its gas; (2) the finding that the parties entered a new agreement in 1981; and (3) the failure to award Tahoe a fair and equitable price based on quantum meruit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.