Louisiana Court of Appeal October 7, 1987, CA-7165 (Delavergne v. Delavergne)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-10-1987

514 So.2d 186 (1987) Louis V. delaVERGNE v. Hugues J. delaVERGNE, II, et al. No. CA-7165. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit. October 7, 1987. Rehearings Denied November 18, 1987. *187 C. Ellis Henican, Henican, James & Cleveland, New Orleans, for defendants-appellants, Hugues J. delaVergne, II and Charles E. delaVergne, Jr. Marcel Garsaud, Jr., Gordon, Arata, McCollam, Stuart & Duplantis, New Orleans, for plaintiff-appellee, Louis V. delaVergne. Before GULOTTA, C.J., and GARRISON and WARD, JJ. WARD, Judge. Hugues J. delaVergne, III and Charles E. delaVergne, Jr. suspensively appeal a money judgment in favor of their brother, Louis V. delaVergne. Louis has answered the appeal and requested modifications of the judgment. The appeals arise from a suit in which Louis sued Hugues and Charles to rescind the partition of the family home, Villa delaVergne, an 87-acre estate in St. Tammany Parish, and to rescind agreements incidental to the partition, on the grounds of lesion and breach of fiduciary duty. In the suit Louis also sought an accounting and a share of the profits Hugues and Charles allegedly made by selling parcels of Villa delaVergne after the partition. Hugues and Charles excepted to the suit, asserting that the partition and incidental agreements constituted a compromise which was res judicata and hence could not be rescinded. In a reconventional demand Hugues and Charles sought damages caused by the notice of lis pendens Louis filed against Villa delaVergne and the expenses of their attorneys fees in this lawsuit. After considering extensive testimony and documentary evidence, a Commissioner of the Civil District Court found insufficient proof of lesion, but recommended rescission of the partition because Hugues *188 and Charles, an attorney and executor, respectively, of their mother's succession, breached the fiduciary duty owed to Louis. Hugues and Charles filed exceptions to the Commissioner's report.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.