District Court, D. Massachusetts December 7, 1987, Civ. A. 87-0090-F (Stern v. Continental Assurance Co. (In Re Ryan))
Also known as
United States · · · 07-12-1987
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
FREEDMAN, Chief Judge.
I.INTRODUCTION
Before this Court is an appeal from a final decision of the bankruptcy court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 158(a). The case concerns the application of a Vermont law which requires that any conveyance of an interest in land be signed by at least two witnesses. 27 Vt.Stat.Ann. § 341 (1985). The appellant is a trustee in bankruptcy who claims that a mortgage executed by the debtor is invalid because it was signed by only one witness. Thus, the trustee claims that the bank, to whom the mortgage was assigned, does not have an enforceable lien against the estate. The bankruptcy court found for the bank stating that the “two witness” rule was a technicality which the Vermont Supreme Court would not interpret so as to invalidate the mortgage.
In Re Ryan,
70 B.R. 509 (Bankr.D.Mass.1987). After careful review of the law, this Court finds that the bankruptcy court erred as a matter of law and was clearly wrong in its interpretation of the Vermont statute. Therefore, the decision will be reversed.
II.FACTS
The facts are undisputed. On November 11, 1975 Thomas E. Ryan (“Debtor”) purchased a condominium unit located in Hartford, Vermont from Quechee Lakes Corporation (the “property”). He executed a mortgage deed the same day to Quechee Lakes Corporation (the “mortgage”). Contrary to the law of Vermont, the mortgage was attested to by only one witness instead of the requisite two. The mortgage was then recorded and on November 17, assigned by Quechee Lakes Corporation to Continental Assurance Corporation (the “bank”). The deed, mortgage and assignment of mortgage were all recorded in the town’s records. Both the deed and mortgage assignment were properly attested to by two witnesses.
The debtor filed for bankruptcy some time in 1983 and Peter M. Stern (“trustee/plaintiff/appellant”) was appointed as trustee for the debtor’s estate.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit