Court of Appeals of Minnesota October 13, 1987, C0-87-1057 (Knutson v. DJM Transport, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-10-1987

OPINION

NORTON, Judge.

Relator Walter Knutson quit his job with respondent DJM Transport and applied for unemployment compensation benefits. A Commissioner’s representative denied Knutson benefits, relying on a prior district court decision and concluding that Knutson did not have good cause to quit his job. We reverse.

FACTS

Walter Knutson began working as an over-the-road truck driver for DJM in September 1985. Knutson was hired as an employee, not as an independent contractor.

When Knutson was hired, he signed an employment agreement that stated he would be “responsible for all shortages.” The agreement also provided that he would be responsible for his food, lodging, and travel expenses, and any “abuse” of DJM’s truck.

On March 29, 1986, Knutson quit his job, claiming DJM had offset shortages from his paychecks without his approval, had failed to pay him in a timely fashion, had breached a promise to pay for his lodging when DJM’s truck broke down, and had refused to remedy the problems when he complained.

After Knutson quit, DJM withheld his last paycheck because Knutson had damaged DJM’s truck. Knutson filed for unemployment compensation benefits. He also commenced a conciliation court action against DJM to recover the money that had been withheld from his paychecks. DJM counterclaimed for the damage sustained by its truck. Knutson obtained a judgment, and DJM appealed. The district court, relying upon the employment agreement, concluded that Knutson was liable for all shortages, that DJM’s deductions for shortages were proper, and that DJM was entitled to offset the damage to its truck against commissions and costs owed Knutson. The court ordered judgment for DJM and against Knutson in the amount of $303.66.

The district court judgment was entered on September 18, 1986, and thereafter Knutson’s claim for unemployment compensation was denied on the basis that he did not have good cause to quit his job.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.