District Court, N.D. Indiana March 19, 1987, Civil H 86-865 (Sheldon v. Munford, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-03-1987

ORDER

MOODY, District Judge.

This matter is before the court on a “Motion to Dismiss Indiana Statutory, Breach of Franchise Agreement, and Negligence Claims” filed by defendants Mun-ford, Inc. (“Munford”) and LeeWards Creative Crafts, Inc. (“LeeWards”) on January 26, 1987. Plaintiffs Robert J. and John M. Sheldon (the “Sheldons”) filed in opposition on February 13, 1987 and the defendants filed a reply on February 25, 1987.

I.

Background

This action arises out of a franchise agreement between the plaintiff Sheldons, citizens of Indiana, and the defendant Mun-ford, a Georgia corporation, which granted the Sheldons an exclusive right to operate a World Bazaar retail store within an exclusive territory including the Southlake Mall in Lake County, Indiana. World Bazaar retail stores are engaged in the sale of imported, domestic and home-decorative gift items.

On or about July 26, 1985, Munford notified all of its World Bazaar franchisees that it had purchased LeeWards, a Delaware corporation. According to the Sheldons’ complaint, LeeWards is a wholly owned subsidiary of Munford. Sheldons maintain that Munford, through its subsidiary LeeWards, unfairly competed with plaintiffs’ South Lake Mall World Bazaar store by selling goods nearly identical to those sold by plaintiffs.

The Sheldons’ complaint, which invokes this court’s subject-matter jurisdiction on the basis of diversity of citizenship, 28 U.S.C. § 1332, alleges that: (1) Munford breached the agreement by allowing their wholly owned subsidiary corporation LeeWards to market and sell products substantially similar and identical to those sold at the Sheldons’ store; (2) Munford breached a reconciliation agreement between the parties which forbade Munford from allowing LeeWards to sell competitive items; (3) Munford violated Ind.Code. 23-2-2.7-2(4) prohibiting a franchisor from competing with its franchisee; and (4) Munford was negligent in allowing LeeWards to compete with the Sheldons.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.