Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court July 13, 1987 (Attorney General v. Weymouth Agricultural & Industrial Society)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-07-1987

Wilkins, J.

The issue is whether the Weymouth Agricultural and Industrial Society (Weymouth) is a “public charity” within the meaning of G. L. c. 12, § 8F (1984 ed.). E so, § 8F obliges Weymouth’s governing board annually to file with the division of public charities in the Department of the Attorney General a written report for its preceding fiscal year, containing

*476

certain financial and other information. Weymouth, which was incorporated under G. L. c. 180 in 1945, has never filed such an annual report.

The Attorney General commenced this action in July, 1980, seeking an order that Weymouth file annual reports. A judge of the Superior Court allowed the Attorney General’s motion for summary judgment and denied Weymouth’s similar motion. We allowed Weymouth’s petition for direct appellate review. We reverse the judgment because Weymouth has not been shown to be a public charity within the meaning of § 8F.

The Attorney General has a mandate under G. L. c. 12, § 8 (1984 ed.), to “enforce the due application of funds given or appropriated to public charities . . . and prevent breaches of trust in the administration thereof.” Although G. L. c. 12, § 8A (1984 ed.), sets forth definitions applicable to § 8F, the term “public charity” is not defined.

1

The meaning of the words “public charity” in § 8F must be determined by application of general principles, both of statutory construction and of what a charity is.

2

We derive no firm guidance from the legislative history of § 8F. As first proposed in 1954, the goal was to require charitable trusts, as defined, to file annual reports. 1954 House Doc. No. 2031. See also Report and Recommendation for Legislation of Former Attorney General Bushnell, Pub. Doc. No. 12 (1945), reprinted in 30 Mass. L. Q. No. 1, at 22 (1945). As enacted, § 8F clearly reaches more than charitable trusts. We think it clear that the Legislature was concerned

*477

with the supervision of entities holding funds committed to charitable purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.