Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court December 21, 1987 (Medi-Cab of Massachusetts Bay, Inc. v. Rate Setting Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-1987

Abrams, J.

This is an appeal by the Rate Setting Commission (commission), pursuant to G. L. c. 30A, § 15, from a final judgment of the Superior Court affirming a decision of the Division of Administrative Law Appeals

1

(division) in which the division approved for the appellee, Medi-Cab, an individual reimbursement rate higher than the class-based rate set for Medi-Cab by the commission. The commission also appeals from the Superior Court judge’s order remanding the case to the commission for promulgation of regulations regarding inclusion of attorney’s fees incurred in rate appeals from the class-based rate.

2

We transferred the case to this court on our

*359

own motion. We modify the Superior Court judgment to order remand of the issue of attorneys’ fees to the division instead of the commission, and, as modified, the decision of the Superior Court judge is affirmed.

I.

Background.

During the years 1975 through 1977, the period covered by this appeal, Medi-Cab provided nonemergency ambulance services (chair-car service) to persons confined in wheelchairs. Many of Medi-Cab’s passengers were recipients of Medicaid or other public assistance. On June 20, 1975, the commission, by its regulation designated 14 C.H.S.R. § 401 (1975),

3

adopted a class-based (or industry wide) reimbursement rate effective August 1, 1975, for Medicaid providers of chair-car services, including Medi-Cab. The commission, by § 401.18 of its regulations, adopted a flat rate of fourteen dollars per trip, plus fifty cents per mile after an initial five miles, plus five dollars for each trip involving two attendants.

Medi-Cab, the primary provider of after-hours and weekend services in its area of operation, believed that it was entitled to an individual cost-based rate, higher than the uniform “class-based” rate promulgated by the commission. Medi-Cab was uncertain, however, of the proper route by which to seek appeal of the fourteen-dollar rate. Two routes appeared open.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.