California Court of Appeal June 9, 1987, B015047 (Maupin v. Widling)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-06-1987
Opinion
GILBERT, J.
Here we hold that the court erred in giving BAJI No. 3.75 (7th ed. 1986)
*
in conjunction with BAJI No. 3.79. The jury was likely confused by the use of two different but alternate tests for establishing cause in fact in a negligence action. We therefore reverse the judgment.
Facts
The defendant Alan Widling was driving along State Street in Santa Barbara on the way back to high school after having lunch. Ahead of Widling by about 20 yards and approaching an intersection was the car driven by Mildred Carlson. Ahead of Carlson, partly protruding from the
*571
extreme left turning lane and waiting for the light to turn green, was the car driven by plaintiff Josephine Maupin.
Widling slowed down to about 20 miles per hour, intending to change lanes to the right. He was looking over his shoulder and then in the rear-view mirror when a passenger in the car warned him to slow down. Widling looked forward to discover he was only two to three feet from the Carlson vehicle, too close to avoid a collision. Now traveling at a speed of 10 to 20 miles per hour, Widling’s car struck the rear end of Carlson’s car, pushing it forward several feet.
Carlson’s car came to a stop for three to five seconds after being hit, according to one witness at trial. But then her car suddenly accelerated so quickly that the front end lifted two feet off the ground while thick black soot fumed from the exhaust pipes. Carlson hit Maupin’s car at a speed of about 20 miles per hour, propelling Maupin’s car into the car in front of her. Maupin’s car was destroyed and Maupin suffered physical injuries.
Maupin settled her claim against Carlson and sued Widling for negligence. At trial the court over objections from Maupin instructed the jury on proximate cause (BAJI No. 3.75) rather than legal cause (BAJI No. 3.76). The court also gave BAJI instruction No. 3.79 on intervening cause. The jury reached a general verdict for the defendant.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit