Supreme Court of Delaware November 30, 1987 (Rainbow Navigation, Inc. v. Pan Ocean Navigation, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-11-1987

HOLLAND, Justice:

This appeal involves an action by Pan Ocean Navigation, Inc. (“Pan Ocean”) for an order permitting it to inspect the books and records of Rainbow Navigation, Inc. (“Rainbow”) pursuant to 8

Del.C.

§ 220. Any stockholder, “upon written demand under oath stating the purpose thereof,” has the right to inspect the corporation’s books and records.

Id.

§ 220(b). However, as used in Section 220 “ ‘stockholder’ means a stockholder of record.”

Id.

§ 220(a). Moreover, the stock ledger is “the only evidence as to who are the stockholders entitled to examine ... the books of the corporation_”

Id.

§ 219(c).

This case raises an important issue of first impression because Rainbow has not maintained a stock ledger and thus, of course, Pan Ocean is not a stockholder of record as defined under a literal reading of Section 219. Nevertheless, Pan Ocean argues that it is a record stockholder of Rainbow and has a right to inspect its books and records, even though Rainbow’s stock ledger is blank. The Court of Chancery conducted a trial and concluded that Pan Ocean is entitled to be treated as record owner of Rainbow stock. We affirm that decision.

Facts

Rainbow Navigation, Inc. is a Delaware corporation which was formed on July 15, 1983 to operate a liner service, primarily transporting U.S. military cargo between the United States and Iceland. Its certificate of incorporation authorized the issuance of 1,000 shares of common stock. Rainbow, however, has never made any entries into its stock ledger.

Pan Ocean Navigation, Inc. is a Nevada corporation which is wholly owned by a pension plan established by a labor union. The pension plan is the Master, Mates and Pilots Individual Retirement Account Plan (“the IRAP”). As of April 1983, the IRAP had entered into an “Investment Management Agreement” with Tower Asset Management, Inc. (“Tower Asset”), contemplating the investment by Tower Asset of some of the IRAP’s trust funds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.