Ohio Court of Appeals September 15, 1987, 87AP-489 (McCoy v. Engle)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1987

Strausbaugh, P.J.

This is an appeal by plaintiff from a judgment of the Court of Claims dismissing his suit for negligence. Judgment was entered by the claims court following remand from this court.

This cause was initiated in the Court of Claims on October 3, 1980 by plaintiff, Russell McCoy, for injuries sustained while plaintiff was incarcerated by defendant, Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. The accident occurred while plaintiff was working on the prison farm located at Chillicothe Correctional Institute. At the time of the incident, plaintiff and another inmate were operating a “collar,” a device used to restrain a bull while undergoing castration. Apparently, plaintiff was injured when the other inmate failed to collar his bull, thus allowing the bull to run in to the area where plaintiff stood. The bull butted plaintiff causing injury to his right bicep muscle.

The Court of Claims rendered judgment in plaintiff’s favor on August 6, 1985 in the amount of $18,000. The claims court found that although plaintiff was an inmate he was also an “employee” for purposes of R.C. 4101.01 (D). As such, the Court of Claims further found that defendant violated R.C. 4101.12, which imposes a duty on an employer to furnish a safe place of employment.

Defendant appealed to this court. We reversed the judgment of the Court of Claims and remanded.

McCoy

v.

Ohio Dept. of Rehabilitation & Correction

(1986), 31 Ohio App. 3d 228, 31 OBR 511, 511 N.E. 2d 398. Reversal was had for the reason that although plaintiffs status as a prisoner did not preclude a finding that he was an “employee” for purposes of R.C. Chapter 4101, the evidence did not support such a finding. Therefore, since the claims court predicated its finding of negligence upon breach of a statutory duty, and made no finding with respect to the existence of a common-law duty, the cause was remanded to that court for further proceedings in accordance with law consistent with the opinion.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.