Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit May 12, 1987, 86-7281 (Kenneth Williams v. Robert R. Kelly, Warden)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1987

TIMBERS, Circuit Judge:

Appellant Robert R. Kelly, Warden of the Deerfield Correctional Center at Ca-pron, Virginia, (“appellant”) appeals from an order entered August 29, 1986 in the Eastern District of Virginia, David G. Lowe,

Magistrate,

which granted a petition by appellee Kenneth Williams (“appellee”) for a writ of habeas corpus. The magistrate granted the petition on the ground that appellee had been denied effective assistance of counsel at his state criminal trial.

Appellee was convicted of felony murder in a Virginia state court after a bench trial. The prosecution’s evidence at trial consisted largely of testimony by a police officer regarding a confession made by appellee. That evidence established that appellee and another man had taken a radio from the victim and that the other man had stabbed and killed the victim. Appellee’s counsel did not move to strike after the prosecution’s case. Appellee then was called to the witness stand and testified regarding other details of the crime. His testimony established clearly that violence had been used before appellee and the other man had taken the victim’s radio. Under Virginia law, appellee could not have been convicted of felony murder unless he participated in a robbery of the victim. An element of robbery in that State is that violence or

*941

intimidation precede or coincide with the taking of property.

In his habeas petition, appellee claimed, first, that he had been denied effective assistance of counsel at his trial, and, second, that the indictment was constitutionally defective. The magistrate, in granting appellee’s petition, held that his counsel’s failure to move to strike after the prosecution’s case, coupled with counsel’s advice to appellee to testify, rendered counsel’s performance constitutionally deficient.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.