Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit May 11, 1987, 86-5617 (Roger Boggs v. Ralph Evitts and Attorney General of Kentucky)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-1987

WELLFORD, Circuit Judge.

Petitioner-appellant, Roger Boggs, convicted in Kentucky state courts of trafficking in a controlled substance, appeals from denial of his habeas corpus petition by the district court. Boggs appealed from his conviction in 1982 to the Kentucky Court of Appeals, which affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed. The Kentucky Supreme Court denied his motion for discretionary review in 1984. Two issues, previously litigated, were presented to the district court as a basis for habeas corpus relief: (1) the trial court’s denial of a continuance due to unavailability of a material witness, and (2) failure to grant Boggs’ motion for a directed verdict based on his theory of entrapment. In addition, Boggs argued before the district court that application of a Kentucky rule of procedure in Kentucky courts amounted to violation of his constitutional right of confrontation.

The controversy was referred by the district judge to Magistrate Joseph M. Hood, who submitted his report and recommendation promptly on the two issues which are construed to be presented in the district court:

First, it is alleged that the trial court’s refusal to grant him a second continuance in which to secure the presence of a missing witness violated rights secured under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments. Second, Boggs claims that the trial court abused his Fifth Amendment rights by failing to grant a directed verdict of acquittal based on the defense of entrapment.

*535

The magistrate concluded that “the substance of both of these arguments has been fairly presented to, and rejected by, the Kentucky courts” and he made a report recommending denial of Boggs’ petition. Timely objections were made to the report. Judge Wilhoit, in approving the report and recommendation, stated that “the first issue raised ... actually challenges the constitutionality of Rule 9.04 of the Kentucky Rules of Criminal Procedure.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.