Palm Beach County Court October 6, 1987, Case No. 87-049298 TT A02 (State v. Dekay)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-10-1987
OPINION OF THE COURT
ROBERT S. SCHWARTZ, County Judge.
*9THIS CAUSE CAME before the Court on October 6, 1987 pursuant to the Defendant’s Motion to Exclude Breath Test Results. The Court having heard argument of counsel, and being otherwise fully advised in the premises, hereby grants the Defendant’s motion.
The Defendant asserts that the operation of the breathalyzer was not in substantial compliance with the regulations of HRS as mandated by F.S. 316.1932(b)(1). This Court, in the case of State v. Hill, 26 Fla. Supp. 2d 82, previously held that the standard to be applied, regarding whether there was substantial compliance, is whether the alleged violation prejudiced the Defendant by raising a legitimate question regarding the authenticity or scientific reliability of the test results. This standard is in consonance with the recent Third DCA case of Gargone v. State, 503 So.2d 421 (3d DCA 1987).
The Defendant was given two tests, within five minutes of one another. The results of the tests show a variation of approximately .021 or more. The Defendant asserts that test results were unacceptable as no third test or blood test was given in violation of the “Note” on the bottom of HRS form 1031. In support of this contention the Defendant cites this Court’s previous decision in State v. Humphries, 25 Fla.Supp.2d 100 (Palm Beach County Ct. 1987) in which this Court held that the “Note” on the bottom of HRS form 1031 was a rule with which there must be substantial compliance.
The “Note” on HRS form 1031 states:
“The two (2) breath tests shall be run no more than five minutes (5) apart and the two results are acceptable if within + or — 0.02%. If more than 0.025 difference, a third (3) test or a blood test should be given . . .”.
The State cites the Circuit Court Appellate Case of State v. Manfredi, 85-595 AC (F) 02 (1986) which addressed this identical issue, but which reached the opposite result.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit