Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit June 19, 1987, 86-5668 (In Re J. David Dominelli, Debtors. M. Larry Lawrence v. Steinford Holding B v. a Netherlands Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1987

*315

PREGERSON, Circuit Judge:

Appellant M. Larry Lawrence (“Lawrence”), a junior lienholder on a jet owned by the bankruptcy estate of J. David. Domi-nelli (“Dominelli”), brought suit against ap-pellee Steinford Holding B.V. (“Steinford”), a senior lienholder on the jet. Lawrence objected to Steinford’s lien on the ground that the loan from which it derived was usurious. The bankruptcy court held that Lawrence could not attack the loan as usurious because the estate’s trustee had brought and then settled a usury claim against Steinford. The district court affirmed the bankruptcy court’s ruling. Lawrence appeals from the district court’s ruling. We affirm. The trustee’s court-approved settlement of the estate’s usury claim against Steinford operates as res ju-dicata to bar Lawrence from again raising the usury claim on behalf of the estate. Moreover, California law does not provide Lawrence with the right to raise the usury defense on his own behalf.

FACTS

In June 1983, Steinford lent Dominelli $3,150,000. Steinford took as security a lien on Dominelli’s Grumman Gulfstream II jet. The loan agreement provided that Dominelli would pay interest at the rate of 22% per annum.

On February 7, 1984, Lawrence lent Dominelli $1,000,000 at the prime rate plus one percent per annum. Lawrence’s loan was secured by a second lien on the same jet. Lawrence’s security agreement specifically was subject to and expressly recognized Steinford’s senior lien.

On February 13, 1984, involuntary petitions in bankruptcy were filed against Dominelli and his various business entities. On June 13, 1984, Lawrence filed suit against Steinford and the estate’s trustee in bankruptcy. In the suit, Lawrence sought to have the interest provisions of Steinford’s note declared void under California law. On July 19, 1984, Steinford brought a motion to dismiss Lawrence’s complaint. Steinford argued, among other things, that Lawrence was not entitled to raise the usury defense.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.