Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit June 17, 1987, 85-2035 (Oklahoma Crude Exploration, an Oklahoma Corporation v. Dow Chemical Company, a Delaware Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-1987

TIMBERS, Circuit Judge.

Appellant Oklahoma Crude Exploration (“appellant”) appeals from the damages portion of a judgment entered June 6, 1985 in the Western District of Oklahoma, Lee R. West,

District Judge,

which, after a jury trial, awarded appellant $22,881.80 in damages on its negligence claim against appellee Dow Chemical Company (“appellee”).

In this diversity action, appellant claimed $91,527.18 representing the costs it incurred in repairing an oil well allegedly damaged by appellee. The court instructed the jury, with respect to the negligence aspect of the case, on Oklahoma’s comparative negligence statute, Okla.Stat.Ann. tit. 23, §§ 13, 14 (West 1987), and submitted to it a verdict form on which to indicate findings as to liability, the percentage of negligence attributable to each party, and the amount of damages to be awarded to appellant. The jury found appellant and appellee each 50% negligent and, on the verdict form, “award[ed] damages in the amount of

U5,763.59.”

In the judgment, the court awarded appellant only one half of $45,763.59 ($22,-881.80). The court apparently believed that it was to perform the computation necessary to reflect the jury’s finding on the percentage of negligence attributable to each party.

On appeal, appellant claims that the court erred in reducing the jury’s award by one-half since the jury already had done so. We agree.

*1435

We hold that the jury instructions, the verdict form, and other factors, all make it clear that the jury itself performed the computation necessary to reflect its findings as to percentages of negligence. The district court erred by again reducing the amount of the jury’s award.

We vacate and remand.

I.

We summarize only those facts believed necessary to an understanding of the issues raised on appeal.

Appellant is an independent oil producer. Appellee is, among other things, an oil field service company.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.