Supreme Court of Rhode Island May 6, 1987, No. 85-191-A (Rucco v. Rhode Island Public Transit Authority)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1987
OPINION
WEISBERGER, Justice.
This case comes before us on cross-appeals by the plaintiffs and the defendant from a judgment entered in the Superior Court following a trial by jury. We affirm. The facts of the case insofar as pertinent to this appeal are as follows.
On August 10, 1979, Roberta Ruceo was the operator of an automobile that had come to a stop on Smith Street in Providence for the purpose of making a left turn when permitted by oncoming traffic. While she was so stopped, her vehicle was struck in the rear by a bus owned by defendant, Rhode Island Public Transit Authority (RIPTA), and operated by its employee. At the time of this collision Roberta was accompanied by her three children one of whom, a child named Bethany, aged fifteen, was injured when her head struck against the headrest of the front seat and then snapped back against the back seat as well. Both Roberta and Bethany required medical treatment. Roberta’s medical expenses consisted of a $20 fee for an emergency-room visit at Notre Dame Hospital and $155 for five visits to Dr. Norbert Fleisig. Roberta presented evidence of loss of earning capacity for a period of three weeks at the rate of $300 per week. The jury returned a verdict in Roberta’s favor in the amount of $3,000.
Bethany claimed loss of earnings of approximately $2,700. She presented evidence of medical bills in the amount of approximately $600 (including diagnostic procedures). She had been treated by Dr. Raymond McKendall, an ophthalmologist, who testified that she had a condition described as “scotoma,” a blind spot that would become apparent if Bethany looked toward her nose. This condition was described by Dr. McKendall as permanent. However, Dr. McKendall testified that her vision would not be impaired in the carrying out of normal activities. The defendant presented an ophthalmologist, Dr. Joseph L. Dowling, Jr., who testified that Bethany’s visual acuity was tested as 20/20 in both eyes in respect to forward vision.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit