Court of Appeals for the First Circuit October 19, 1987, 87-1160 (Bruce Paul Witte v. Justices of the New Hampshire Superior Court)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-10-1987

PER CURIAM.

Plaintiff, alleging that the New Hampshire Marital Master Program was unconstitutional and that, as his domestic problems had not yet been finally resolved, he faced a realistic risk of being subjected to it in the near future, brought an action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 seeking declaratory and injunctive relief. The district court, without holding an evidentiary hearing, dismissed the action on the ground that the marital master system satisfied the essentials of due process. Plaintiff has appealed.

1

Plaintiff contends that the due process clause requires that cases be decided by judges. Marital masters, however, are not judges, at least as defined by state law (under the New Hampshire Constitution, judges are nominated and appointed by the governor and council and hold their office during good behavior, N.H. Const, pt. 2, arts. 46, 73), but rather are lawyers, removable at will.

See

New Hampshire Superior Court Administrative Rules 12-6, 12-7 (marital masters appointed for a three year period, but, notwithstanding their appointment, serve at the pleasure of the court). Consequently, plaintiff feels the marital master system is unconstitutional.

Even if we were to assume without deciding that due process requires domestic relations cases to be determined by persons with greater tenure than marital masters, we would find no merit in plaintiff’s contention. Plaintiff proceeds as if marital masters have the authority, over the objection of the parties, to finally determine cases. They do not. Rather, they may only make recommendations, and the recommendations have “no binding force upon the court.”

Opinion of the Justices,

128 N.H. 17, 20, 509 A.2d 746, 748 (1986). Masters have no inherent power, but rather derive all their power from the appointing judge or from the agreement of the parties.

See

N.H.Rev.StatAnn. § 519:9; R. Wiebusch, 5 New Hampshire Civil Practice and Procedure § 1371 (1984).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.