Court of Appeals of Texas January 14, 1987, No. 04-85-00510-CR (Meyer v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1987

OPINION

Before BUTTS, DIAL and CHAPA, JJ.

BUTTS, Justice.

A jury found appellant guilty of attempted murder and assessed punishment at 15 years’ imprisonment and a $10,000.00 fine.

All the points of error question the admission of reputation testimony at the guilt/innocence stage of trial. Points one and two concern reputation testimony of appellant’s former wife and the complainant, her boyfriend. Points three and four look to the reputation testimony of State’s witnesses Juan Cubillos and Joanna Gonzales.

Appellant admitted he shot the complainant with a shotgun. The scene was at the complainant’s ranch gate on a highway south of the “party house” where appellant saw the complainant with his former wife, Mary Esther Delgado. Appellant claimed self-defense.

Points of error one and two raise the objection that appellant’s reputation had not been placed in issue when the State erroneously presented reputation testimony from two State’s witnesses, the former wife, Delgado, and the complainant, Morales.

The prosecutor asked Delgado on direct examination during the guilt/innocence stage of trial:

Q: Ms. Delgado, do you know the reputation of [appellant] in the community in which he resides, here in Bexar County—

A: Yes, sir.

Q: —for being violent?

*294A: Yes, sir.

Defense Counsel: Your Honor, I’m going to object. That’s an improper ■ predicate.

This objection was sustained. After other attempts to lay a predicate, the State then asked:

Q: Ms. Delgado, do you know the general reputation of [appellant] in the community where he resides for violence?

Defense Counsel: Your Honor, here again, I’m going to object. General reputation is not in issue.

THE COURT: Overruled, (emphasis added)

A series of objections delayed the final reputation question. The trial court sustained the immediate next objection as to improper predicate. But it overruled the third objection to the question whether she had talked to other people that knew appellant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.