Court of Appeals of Texas June 4, 1987, No. 09-86-041 CV (Williamson v. M & E Food Mart, Inc., 2)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-06-1987
OPINION
BURGESS, Justice.
Mary Williamson and husband, Jim, filed suit against M & E Food Mart, Inc., #2 and its employees Charles Gaudet and Randy Westbrook. Mrs. Williamson alleged she had been injured in an incident in the Market Basket Food Store in Kirbyville, Texas. She sought past and future damages for her injuries. Mr. Williamson sought damages for loss of consortium and household services. A jury found both Mrs. Williamson and Randy Westbrook negligent. They awarded medical expenses but no other damages. The trial court refused to submit jury issues on Mr. Williamson’s damages. We reverse and remand as to both Williamsons.
We reverse as to Mrs. Williamson on her point of error that the jury’s failure to award damages for physical pain and mental anguish in the past is so against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence as to be manifestly unfair, inadequate and unjust. The uncontroverted evidence was that Mrs. Williamson was shopping in the Market Basket Store and she was looking into a “cold cuts” bin buying bacon. Mrs. Williamson had parked her shopping cart near a door which led from a storage area to the customer produce area. Randy Westbrook came through the door pushing a cart loaded with produce. The door or Westbrook’s cart hit Mrs. Williamson’s cart, which hit her in the temple, knocking her onto the cooler and then onto the floor.
There was considerable quarrel about whether or not Mrs. Williamson was injured and the extent of those injuries. The Williamsons sought to prove that Mrs. Williamson suffered a back injury and produced evidence to that effect. The store sought to show that Mrs. Williamson had made several statements to the effect that she was “all right” and was not injured, Unbelievably, the jury was not asked directly whether or not Mrs. Williamson suffered an iniulT on the occasion in question. They were asked the damage issue in the following manner:
SPECIAL ISSUE NO.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit