Tennessee Supreme Court July 20, 1987 (P & P Enterprises, Inc. v. Celauro)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-07-1987

OPINION

PER CURIAM.

Plaintiff-Appellee, P & P Enterprises, Inc., d/b/a New Image Tans, brought suit for recovery of amusement tax, penalty and interest thereon, assessed by the Department of Revenue. The Defendant-Appellant, Commissioner of Revenue, appeals from the judgment entered against her in the Chancery Court of Madison County. The Chancellor found that “Plaintiff’s tanning bed operation is not a taxable amusement pursuant to T.C.A. § 67-6-212.” The sole issue before us is a legal one, whether the Tennessee Amusement Tax applies to tanning beds.

Plaintiff initially sought to have all tanning bed owners who were current with the Department of Revenue in their payments of taxes, penalties and interest, certified as a class, pursuant to Rule 23.02, T.R.C.P. The Chancellor noted that the requisites for a class action had been met, however since this was a tax recovery suit a class action was “not appropriate” and Plaintiff’s motion for class certification was denied. Plaintiff avers on appeal that this was error.

The facts in this case were not in dispute; therefore, there being no genuine issue as *879to any material fact, this was a proper case for summary judgment. In his Order granting Plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment, the Chancellor made certain findings of fact. He found that Plaintiff is in the business of providing tanning services or tanning beds to customers for a charge. Tanning clients are generally repeat clients, most of whom have paid for tanning a few months in advance. The charges range from $40.00 for nine visits to $450 for one year. Advance payment entitles the clients to expose themselves to ultraviolet radiation in a “tanning bed” for a specified period of time. Commercial suntanning through the use of tanning beds became popular in the United States about 1977. Health spas or clubs include tanning services and tanning beds among those services and equipment typically provided.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.