Court of Appeals of Tennessee November 4, 1987 (Derryberry v. Hill)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1987

OPINION

LEWIS, Judge.

This is an appeal by plaintiffs from the granting of defendants’ Rule 41.02(2), Tenn.R.Civ.P., motion to dismiss the complaint at the close of plaintiffs’ proof.

The facts out of which this controversy arose are as follows:

Plaintiffs wished to sell their 158 acre tract of land located near Spring Hill, Mau-ry County, Tennessee (hereafter the “property”).

Prior to May 14, 1985, Mr. Derryberry had discussed listing the “property” with defendant, L.D. Hill, but had not done so. In early May 1985, defendant, Larry Hub-bell, went to plaintiffs’ home to solicit the listing of the “property.” On May 14, 1985, Mr. Hubbell and Mr. Derryberry entered into a listing agreement for the sale of the “property” in the sum of $249,500. The agreement was with Larry Hubbell Realty, a company owned by defendant Hubbell. Mr. Derryberry preferred selling the “property” as one tract, even though Mr. Hubbell advised him that it would bring more if it were divided into smaller tracts.

Mr. Hubbell advertised the “property” but there was little interest. To Mr. Derry-berry’s knowledge, Mr. Hubbell only brought one potential buyer to the “property” between May 14, 1985, and June 14, 1985.

On June 14, 1985, Mr. Hubbell met with Mr. Derryberry and advised him that he and defendant Steve Hill were interested in purchasing the “property” and offered Mr. Derryberry $215,000. Mr. Derryberry rejected the offer and countered with an offer to sell for $237,500 with the understanding that plaintiffs would pay a real estate commission out of the $237,500. Mr. Hubbell did not advise plaintiffs that he would split the sales commission with L.D. Hill & Sons Realty Company. Mr. Hubbell had with him a sales contract, signed by both himself and Steve Hill, which showed the consideration to be $215,000. Mr. Hub-bell informed Mr. Derryberry that he would have to present the counter-proposal to Steve Hill.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.