Court of Appeals of Tennessee November 5, 1987 (Vakil v. Idnani)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-11-1987
CRAWFORD, Judge.
Plaintiffs, Suresh P. Vakil, and wife Su-dha S. Vakil, buyers under a real estate sales contract sued sellers, Rajengra G. Idnani and wife, Hoor R. Idnani, for a rescission of the contract, and the deed and security instruments executed in closing the transaction. At the conclusion of the nonjury trial, the trial court entered an order denying rescission, but ordering a reformation of the warranty deed from the seller to the buyer. The buyers have appealed and present three issues for review which we quote from their brief:
1. In an action for rescission, were plaintiffs/appellants entitled to rescission as a result of mutual mistake without being required to prove fraud, either actual or constructive?
2. Where the plaintiffs/appellants have elected the remedy of rescission, may the trial court deny such election of remedies and grant the relief sought by defendants/appellees?
3. Alternatively, if a showing of fraud is required in a rescission action, did the trial court err in failing to hold that fraud was established under the facts of this case?
Plaintiff, Suresh P. Vakil, and defendant, Rajengra G. Idnani, were the only witnesses to testify and the trial court correctly noted that “there’s very little difference in the testimony in this case.” We will briefly set out the pertinent facts as established by the proof.
The buyers and sellers reached an agreement for buyers to purchase sellers’ motel in Cleveland, Tennessee, and together they prepared and executed a document setting out their agreement, which we quote:
REAL ESTATE SALES CONTRACT FOR FRIENDLY INN MOTEL
Buyers: Suresh P. Vakil & Sudha S. Vakil
Sellers: Rajendra G. Idnani and Hoor P. Idnani
Buyers and sellers hereby enter into an agreement for sale of the Friendly Inn *198Motel under the conditions setforth inhere.
1) Sellers agree to sell and buyers agree to buy the Friendly Inn Motel located at 1211 South Lee hwy, Cleveland, Tn 37311.
2) Purchase price will be $450,000.00.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit