New York Supreme Court February 6, 1987 (Merced v. City of New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-02-1987

OPINION OF THE COURT

Barry Salman, J.

The defendant’s motion for a judgment notwithstanding the verdict or a request for a new trial or in the alternative to set aside the verdict on the grounds of excessiveness as to damages is disposed of as follows:

The jury returned a verdict against the City of New York in the sum of $84,000 for conscious pain and suffering and $960,000 for the wrongful death of the decedent.

On June 3, 1982, at approximately 12:55 a.m., two police officers accepted a call from a 911 dispatcher. The dispatcher related that the calls had been received from tenants residing at 3435 Giles Place. The complainants reported that they had heard loud screams coming from apartment 7A and that a man with a gun was seen near the apartment. The police officer arrived at the designated address, entered the vestibule and rang apartment 7A’s bell, so that they could gain entry into the building.

After receiving no response they returned to their patrol car and told 911 to call the complainant back so that she could buzz them into the building. Upon their return to the vestibule the officers were "buzzed” in, presumably by one of the complainants. As soon as the officers entered the lobby they encountered a tenant, who was not one of the complain*444ants, but who nevertheless proceeded to inform the officers that everything was quiet and that it was probably just a family dispute. Whereupon the police officers departed without any further investigation. The officers never left the vestibule; they did not go up to the seventh floor to investigate the incident.

Shortly after, the 911 dispatcher received another call from a prior caller stating that the police had not yet responded and that emergency assistance was needed. The 911 dispatcher contacted the same police officers, who stated that all was well and under control. The officers did not return to the building to investigate. The following morning the body of Ms. Merced was discovered by her neighbors. Ms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.