New York Court of Claims February 23, 1987, Claim No. 72315 (Sky Four Realty Co. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-1987

OPINION OF THE COURT

Donald J. Corbett, Jr., J.

Claimant, a New York State real estate partnership owns Loudon Plaza, a shopping center in Albany, New York. As owner and lessor, claimant on February 24, 1976 leased a portion of its plaza to C.F.M. Enterprises, Inc. (CFM), for the purpose of operating a convenience food market. CFM thereafter entered into a sublease or franchise agreement (neither was offered into evidence at trial), commencing on May 7, 1976 with one Fischer (lessee), to operate the Convenient Food Mart. That agreement terminated on or about August 18, 1985.

The lessee had applied on July 17, 1976 pursuant to the "New York state lottery for education law” (State lottery) for *811permission to sell lottery tickets to the general public. Permission was granted and the lessee sold "instant game” lottery tickets until his agreement with CFM terminated. On February 4, 1984, after receiving approval from the State lottery, the lessee also commenced the sale of "on-line” lottery tickets. The "on-line” tickets were issued through a computer terminal on the premises and continued until the agreement with CFM terminated. A new lessee, succeeding Fischer, received approval from the State lottery and commenced the sale of "on-line” tickets on September 13, 1985.

The claimant herein, on or about July 11, 1985, apparently concluded that the installation of the computer terminal and sale of "on-line” lottery tickets was violative of its lease agreement with CFM, in the absence of the landlord’s consent. Claimant then demanded of both CFM and the State lottery the immediate removal of the lottery equipment, and cessation of all such putatively violative activity. Upon the trial herein there had been no compliance with such demand. (On October 3, 1986, Justice Harold J.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.