New York Supreme Court April 23, 1987 (People v. Walker)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-04-1987
OPINION OF THE COURT
David Stadtmauer, J.
Assigned counsel submits vouchers with respect to his representation of an indigent defendant. The claim is for 255.5 hours expended in court and 137 hours expended out of court, for a total of $13,490.
The charges against the defendant were serious and included a count of murder in the second degree. The defense was vigorous and resulted in a complete acquittal. To the extent indicated, it cannot be denied that counsel provided valuable services to the defendant.
In determining a proper allowance for counsel, the court must look not only at the hours actually spent but must also take into consideration a number of other factors — not the least of which is the manner in which the time was expended (see, People v Perry, 27 AD2d 154, 163).
The trial was, concededly, lengthy — but this was due, in large measure, to lengthy and unabated applications by defense counsel. These applications began even before the Wade hearing and included, inter alla, demands for discovery beyond what counsel could reasonably expect that he was entitled to; repeated applications of questionable merit for the recusal of the Assistant District Attorney; repeated demands for names, addresses, and telephone numbers of the People’s witnesses after applications for such discovery had been denied by the court; lengthy, unreasonably verbose, and redundant arguments even in the face of repeated admonitions by the court; and unreasonable demands that every innocuous conversation, whether at side-Bar, in open court or in chambers, be recorded.
During jury selection, scarcely a juror escaped a proposed challenge for cause, each such challenge articulated at great length on the record. Indeed, the entire panel was challenged as unconstitutionally assembled and the prosecutor was groundlessly accused of bias and prejudice in systematically excluding blacks.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit