New York Supreme Court May 29, 1987 (Cier Industries Co. v. New York State Division of Housing & Community Renewal)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1987

*1004OPINION OF THE COURT

David B. Saxe, J.

The issue raised in these proceedings is of fundamental importance to the administration of the so-called "hardship” provisions of the Rent Stabilization Law in New York City. The Rent Stabilization Law (Administrative Code of City of New York § YY51-1.0 et seq., renum § 26-501 et seq.) has historically incorporated "hardship” provisions in recognition of the fact that an owner may not be able to earn the return on its capital investment that is prescribed by statute. If successful, an applicant for a "hardship” increase is issued an order by the Rent Guidelines Board. In 1983, "hardship” rental increases under an alternative hardship formula were made available to owners who were not able to maintain an annual gross rental income for the building which exceeded the annual operating expenses by a sum equal to at least 5% of the gross rents. (L 1983, ch 403, §§ 9, 49, adding Administrative Code § YY51-6.0 [c] [6-a], renum § 26-511 [c] [6-a].)

In these two CPLR article 78 proceedings, the court is asked to determine whether alternative hardship applications can be applied for by owners of unsold rent-stabilized apartments in cooperative and condominium buildings. In Matter of Cier Indus. v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal (DHCR) (index No. 23856/86), the owner of various units in a building located at 80 Park Avenue which was converted to condominium ownership had applied for but was denied consideration for any alternative hardship relief. Similarly, in Matter of Sharp & Lufkin v New York State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal (index No. 23857/86), the owner of unsold shares in a cooperative building located at 203/205 East 72nd Street had applied for but was denied consideration of their alternative hardship application. The DHCR concluded that the statute offers this relief only to owners of buildings.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.