Nassau County District Court July 21, 1987 (People v. Delta Carting Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-07-1987
OPINION OF THE COURT
Ira B. Warshawsky, J.
The defendant was charged with operating an auto car-*269dump truck, commonly known as a garbage truck, where the weight on the rear axles was greater than 36,000 pounds, to wit: 62,000 pounds, in violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law § 385 (9). After the People’s case, the defendant moved to dismiss due to the failure of the People to prove a prima facie case as to each element of the crime. Specifically, the defendant argued and one of the People’s witnesses agreed that the police did not check to see if the truck was "loaded” when it was stopped and weighed. The court denied the motion and allowed the defendant to renew his motion upon submission of a memorandum of law at the end of the entire case. Both sides have submitted and the court will now address that issue.
Vehicle and Traffic Law § 385 (9) states: "The weight on any two consecutive axles of a single vehicle or a combination of vehicles, equipped with pneumatic tires, when loaded, and when such axles are spaced less than eight feet from center to center, shall be not more than thirty-six thousand pounds, except where axles are spaced eight feet or greater, but less than ten feet, the weight on those two axles shall not exceed that permitted by paragraph (b) of subdivision ten of this section and, in addition, shall not exceed forty thousand pounds. Axles to be counted as provided in subdivision five of this section.”
The referred to exception deals with axles greater than 8 feet but less than 10 feet apart, and provides that the permitted weight on the axles shall not exceed that allowed by section 385 (10) (b). When we refer to subdivision (10) (b), we see the same phrase, "when loaded”, used in line 2 of subdivision (10). As we proceed first to paragraph (a), the words "total weight” appear and then in paragraph (b) "overall gross weight” is the verbiage used preceding the formula to determine maximum weight.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit