New York Court of Claims July 31, 1987, Claim No. 70854 (Turiano v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-07-1987
*597OPINION OF THE COURT
Frank S. Rossetti, J.
Motion by claimant for partial summary judgment (CPLR 3212 [e])1 granted in part and denied in part, in accordance with the following.
In this appropriation claim, claimant moves to have a title question determined, to wit, title to land under water adjacent to upland owned by claimant and appropriated by the State. Mr. Turiano claims title to such underwater land under a grant from the State pursuant to article 6 of the Public Lands Law. This grant was subject to a condition, but claimant contends it was a condition subsequent which became void upon the vesting of title in the State under the subject appropriation. The State argues the condition was a condition precedent which was never fulfilled and therefore title never vested in claimant. On the limited question presented, we find the subject grant conveyed claimant a fee on condition subsequent to the underwater land and he retained at least that title up to the time of the claimed appropriation.
Prior to 1969, claimant and his brother2 owned property bordering on tidal waters and wetlands of Great Neck Bay off Long Island. Claimant’s property was located just inside the City of New York line, in the Borough and County of Queens. Claimant wanted to improve the property with mooring and docking facilities and he applied to the State Commissioner of General Services for a grant to the underwater land adjacent to his upland (see, Public Lands Law § 10; 9 NYCRR part 270). The application was made for claimant’s "beneficial enjoyment” of the land (see, Public Lands Law § 75 [7]; 3 Warren’s Weed, New York Real Property, Land Under Water § 3.04) and a hearing was held October 29, 1968 because of an adverse claim by the City of New York (see, 9 NYCRR 270.8, 270.9; 3 Warren’s Weed, dp. cit., § 4.05 [3] [d]). However, the city defaulted at the hearing and the State Attorney-General issued a report November 20, 1968 advising that the applied-for grant could be made.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit