New York Supreme Court August 31, 1987 (People v. Beirati)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-08-1987
OPINION OF THE COURT
Herbert Shapiro, J.
Is a potential juror, who had previously served On a jury where the indictment charged the crime of attempted murder, subject to a challenge for cause on the trial of a subsequent indictment for attempted murder involving a different incident and a different defendant? This was the question raised by the defendant’s attorney during the jury selection process in the instant case and which he contended should be answered in the affirmative.
The almost reflex reaction of the court was that such contention was frivolous and should be summarily rejected.* Defendant, however, persisted and pointed to the language of subdivision (1) (e) of CPL 270.20. That provision reads as follows:
"1. A challenge for cause is an objection to a prospective juror and may be made only on the ground that * * *
"(e) He served on the grand jury which found the indictment in issue or served on a trial jury in a prior civil or criminal action involving the same conduct charged in such indictment”.
Defendant contends that a literal reading of the subdivision requires that a juror who has served on one trial jury involving a charge of attempted murder may not thereafter serve on another trial jury where the charge to be tried is attempted murder, irrespective of whether there is any relationship between the specific acts or the defendants in the two cases.
A reading of the language of the subdivision leads one to conclude that the argument made by defendant may not be quite as frivolous as this court initially thought it to be. What is meant by the phrase "involving the same conduct”? Does it mean — as defendant contends — merely the same crime or does it mean the same incident and/or the same defendant?
Research has proven to be of little assistance. The only *961reported case found (People v Calmbacher, 103 Misc 405) which touches the question, dealt with an interpretation of the predecessor statute (Code Crim Pro § 377 [5]).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit