New York Supreme Court October 26, 1987 (Austin v. Delligatti)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-10-1987

OPINION OF THE COURT

Vincent R. Balletta, Jr., J.

This proceeding was commenced pursuant to CPLR article 4 by order to show cause by the petitioner Leonard B. Austin, the Democratic candidate for Supervisor of the Town of Oyster Bay, seeking an order declaring, inter alia, that certain conduct of the respondents is false and fraudulent.

The petitioner contends that various campaign signs and *531literature which contain the word "return” with respect to Angelo Delligatti are false and fraudulent since Mr. Delligatti is not the incumbent Supervisor of the Town of Oyster Bay. He requests that this court order the removal of those signs or political advertisements which contain the word "return”, and grant a further order preventing the erection of additional signs or advertisements and the distribution of literature which contains the word "return”. In addition, he requests money damages "to pay for corrective political advertising.”

The respondents have raised as a threshold question the argument that the court has no jurisdiction in this matter since the petitioner has failed to make a complaint pursuant to the Fair Campaign Code (9 NYCRR 6201.1 et seq. [Code]), and section 3-106 of the Election Law, entitled "Fair campaign code”, which requires the State Board of Elections to adopt a Fair Campaign Code "setting forth ethical standards of conduct for persons, political parties and committees engaged in election campaigns” (§ 3-106 [1]). Among other things, subdivision (3) of section 3-106 provides: "The state board of elections, on its own initiative, or upon complaint or otherwise, may investigate any alleged violation of the fair campaign code and, in appropriate cases, may apply for an order, as provided in this article.”

In addition, section 3-102 of the Election Law states that "the state board of elections shall have the power and duty to:

"1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.