New York Supreme Court September 15, 1987 (Ponterio v. Regan)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1987

OPINION OF THE COURT

Harold J. Hughes, J.

The petition for a judgment annulling the respondent’s determination of December 18, 1986, which decided that petitioner’s retirement application was received by the Comptroller one day too late to permit him to be eligible for the early retirement incentive credit offered by his employer, and declaring that he is entitled to the benefit of Laws of 1986 (ch 177), will be granted, without costs. Laws of 1984 (ch 665) authorized employers participating in the New York State Retirement System to offer their employees an early retire*588ment incentive program. The Tonawanda City School District decided to offer such a program, to be open for a 90-day period commencing on May 3, 1985. Those employees who opted to retire during the 90-day open period received a 6% increase in their retirement benefits, and the addition of three years to their service time.

Petitioner was the attorney for the school district with 17 years in the Retirement System. He decided to take advantage of the early retirement incentive and resigned from his position effective June 29, 1985. Section 3 (iv) of chapter 665 defines an eligible employee as one who "files an application for service retirement that is effective during the open period as specified by the participating employer” (emphasis supplied). The Comptroller has construed section 70 of the Retirement and Social Security Law as requiring that an application for retirement must be on file with the Retirement System for at least 30 days before it becomes "effective”. The last day of the 90-day open period of the school district’s retirement incentive program was July 31, 1985. To have an "effective” application for service retirement on file during the 90-day open period, an employee had to file his application for retirement benefits no later than July 1, 1985.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.