Ohio Supreme Court September 2, 1987, No. 86-887 (Saccucci v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-09-1987

lead-opinion

Per Curiam.

The issue in this case is whether the policy language relied upon by State Farm is a valid and enforceable limitation which prohibits Saccucci from stacking the uninsured motorist coverages under the three policies.

The relevant contract language is set forth in the uninsured motor vehicle and underinsured motor vehicle coverage section of the policies:

“If There Is Other Uninsured Motor Vehicle Coverage

a* * *

“3. If the insured is injured while occupying a vehicle not owned by you, your spouse or any relative, this coverage applies:

“a. as excess to any uninsured motor vehicle coverage which applies to the vehicle as primary coverage, but “b. only in the amount by which it exceeds the primary coverage.

“If coverage under more than one policy applies as excess:

“a. the total limit of liability shall not exceed the difference between the limit of liability of the coverage that applies as primary and the highest limit of liability of any one of the coverages that apply as excess; and

“b. we are liable only for our share. Our share is that per cent of the damages that the limit of liability of this coverage bears to the total of all uninsured motor vehicle coverage applicable as excess to the accident.” (Emphasis sic.)

The court of appeals below found that the first half (the first “a” and “b,” plus preamble) of the disputed provision constituted an “excess-escape” clause which seeks to avoid or limit recovery. Under this clause State *275Farm would pay nothing to Saccucci. The court of appeals found such avoidance of indemnification was contrary to the holding in Curran v. State Auto. Mut. Ins. Co. (1971), 25 Ohio St. 2d 33, 54 O.O. 2d 166, 266 N.E. 2d 566, because a result of no indemnification was repugnant to the uninsured motorist statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.