United States Court of Claims March 17, 1987, No. 454-86C (Sterlingwear of Boston, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-03-1987

OPINION

REGINALD W. GIBSON, Judge:

I. Statement of the Case

This opinion is the third in a series of opinions which have issued in this case stemming from the plaintiffs’ now seven-month old challenge to the award of a government contract premised on IFB DLA-100-85-B-1327 for the manufacture of women’s overcoats ordered by the U.S. *881Navy.1 This latest opinion addresses the government’s December 31,1986 converted motion for summary judgment seeking to dismiss the plaintiffs’ complaint on the ground that plaintiffs have been legally debarred2 by the Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) of the Department of Defense and are therefore precluded from any award of the subject contract (FAR § 9.405(a) and (b)). Previously, on August 13, 1986, following a two-day hearing on July 31 and August 1, 1986, the court preliminarily enjoined the DLA from issuing an award on the subject contract to any bidder other than the plaintiffs, pending a decision on plaintiffs’ debarment. Sterlingwear v. United States, 10 Cl.Ct. 644 (1986). That opinion also ordered the defendant to report to the court as soon as any determination was reached by DLA on the then proposed debarment of the plaintiffs noticed on July 3, 1986.

On November 18, 1986, the court was informed by defendant that all named plaintiffs in this action had received notice of their debarment by DLA. Whereupon, in addition to their initial challenges to DLA’s decision^ to deny them the award of the subject contract, and to even initiate the debarment proceeding, plaintiffs now aver that the actual debarment proceedings were defective in that they were denied fundamental due process. This is so because they were not accorded an opportunity to cross-examine the individual who provided the government’s main source of information in the debarment proceedings regarding genuine factual issues material to the propriety of the debarment. See plaintiffs’ Memorandum filed December 5, 1986.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.